Home > Forensics > Effectiveness of DNA Identifiers

Effectiveness of DNA Identifiers

By: Ian Murnaghan BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 7 Mar 2014 | comments*Discuss
 
Dna Identifier Identification Ruling

Using DNA to identify a person is not as much of an exact science as some people may believe. For example, there is a great deal of judgment and common sense that must be involved and also a consideration of other types of evidence in criminal investigations. While in some instances, the match may be 'perfect' enough to conclusively show that evidence links to a suspect, other times it may not be so clear-cut and the match may be less obvious.

Using DNA to Create a Match

While humans share much of the same DNA, there are still some variations that can be exploited for identification purposes. By comparing the regions that differ from one person to another, scientists can match up evidence or link two people together from a familial line as well as perform other useful applications. There are thirteen DNA regions that are analysed to create a DNA profile for criminal investigations.

Making a DNA Match

You may be wondering just how accurate this type of identification is, given that a mistake could result in major consequences, particularly in instances of proving guilt or innocence in a crime.

DNA evidence needs to be used carefully and with common sense as well. If you think about evidence in a criminal investigation, you know that common sense will dictate that one piece of evidence in itself is not necessarily strong enough to point to a specific perpetrator. For instance, if investigators knew that a footprint was left from a size eight shoe, this would not be enough because many people have shoes of this size. If a piece of black hair were left behind as well, the two pieces of evidence would be more helpful in narrowing down to a perpetrator.

Try to consider DNA evidence in that same light. A forensic scientist will investigate a DNA sequence by looking for a match in specific bits of the DNA sequence. While one or even a couple of matches are not that strong to indicate a match between two DNA profiles, four or even better - five - are significantly stronger and can provide more confidence that there is an accurate match between two profiles.

Also keep in mind that there may be several suspects in a case. This means that it is not simply a case of looking for a match between evidence and one person, but it requires comparing the number of matching regions collectively from one suspect to another. One suspect may only show a few matching regions, another may show half and yet another may show all thirteen. The probability would therefore indicate that the suspect with all thirteen regions matching the evidence is the culprit.

Matching and Probabilities

Probability is a large part of making a DNA match in a crime scene investigation. Investigators must look at the probability of a person matching a random sample of DNA evidence. The probability is highest for a person matching a random sample at just one region and this would not be a strong enough match to show that the person was at the crime scene. The probability goes down with each subsequent region match until all thirteen regions match, which would indicate a probability of virtually zero.

DNA evidence can sway a case toward a suspect but it is clearly not always a simple, straightforward process of analysing a suspect's DNA and immediately ruling that person out or conclusively pointing the finger. Depending on how close the DNA matches, other pieces of evidence will need to be taken into account to help determine a person's innocence or guilt. Still, despite the challenges of using DNA to identify a person, we are fortunate to have this technology because its benefits far exceed any difficulties.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Ankesh
    Re: The Properties of DNA
    Please explain the properties with diagram...it helps to understand the topic Easley
    19 September 2019
  • Kitty
    Re: Using DNA and for Immigration Purposes
    I have 3 children for my ex partner he came to me and told me that immigration have asked for birth certificate of my…
    28 August 2019
  • Laverne
    Re: Using DNA and for Immigration Purposes
    Hi..i am a USC. I petition for my stepchildren who are in Jamaica and the petition has been approved. I have since…
    9 August 2019
  • Mhay
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    I need some answer...my son died 24 years ago, August 6,1995, he was born July 29,1995, I just have doubts in my mind, as Fabella Hospital in…
    30 July 2019
  • mich
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    I would like to know if an old baseball cap would have my father's dna. My dad passed away in 2010.
    30 July 2019
  • Gurl
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    My grandmother passed and I want to do a DNA-genealogical test. I did the 23 and me test and it was revealed I am 47percent Native American.…
    26 July 2019
  • fredab
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    hi , my son passed away ,17 years ago in2001 and he had a baby on the way ,she was born in june 2002 , she is 17 years old now ,but we had…
    27 June 2019
  • Richie
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    My sister was adopted by my Aunty at a very young age. We met for the first time when I was 35 years old and she was 45 years. We were in…
    25 June 2019
  • spearmannbails
    Re: DNA and Criminology
    no. deoxyribonucleic acid is to be for biology, and biology only.
    24 June 2019
  • Casey
    Re: DNA Testing for Pets
    Hi, I was wondering if there was any chance you could do a DNA test on my dogs ashes, for a long time we suspected he wasnt full Siberian…
    18 June 2019