Home > Agriculture > DNA and Environmental Challenges

DNA and Environmental Challenges

By: Ian Murnaghan BSc (hons), MSc - Updated: 2 Jan 2013 | comments*Discuss
 
Dna Environment Environmental Challenges

DNA discovery and technology have allowed us to develop the tools to perform genetic modification (GM) on organisms. Unfortunately, there are environmental challenges and concerns that shadow the promise of GM technology.

Understanding Genetic Modification

Genetic modification operates on the premise that a desired gene from one organism can be inserted into a recipient organism that normally does not have that gene. This 'mixing and matching' allows scientists to manipulate an organism's genome to provide benefits to areas such as agriculture. A vegetable can be engineered to withstand a drought or a coffee bean could be engineered to be caffeine-free. The possibilities are virtually endless but numerous challenges, particularly in relation to the environment, have kept GM technology from being accepted by all members of the public and scientific community. In fact, GM foods are banned in certain areas of the world and until long-term studies are performed to assess their full impact on the environment, it is likely that controversy will prevail.

Gene Transfer

When GM crops are grown, there is the potential for genes to be transferred to other organisms in the environment. This creates the possibility of uncontrolled growth, which could be a real threat if any unexpected and dangerous consequences arose from the gene transfer. Still, a great many crops are not actually native to the fields where they are grown. As such, no related species may be present to facilitate gene flow. In addition, if a transfer of genes did occur, the resulting species may not survive at all because the traits would not be beneficial in that particular environment. Another aspect to consider is that GM technology may itself evolve to allow techniques to prevent gene transfer from one crop to another.

Harm to Other Organisms in the Environment

There is still conflicting evidence concerning the effects of GM technology on other organisms in the environment. One concern is that GM crops that are engineered to be resistant to insects could harm insects or other species. One experiment found adverse effects when caterpillars consumed GM foods. Other effects are considered positive such as reduced need for pesticides and herbicides. It has, however, been argued that resistance may eventually occur so any benefit would be short-lived.

Issues in Assessing Environmental Impact of GM Crops

Not only is there much debate regarding the precise environmental impact but there is also debate regarding how to actually assess the impact of GM crops on the environment. Most of the scientific community and the public seem to agree that we should be assessing the impact and that ignoring it will likely only lead to further issues in the future. It would seem that an effective approach would be to look at the impact on a case-by-case basis, which would thus depend on the specific species, the genes involved and the ecosystem itself.

It would also be wise to look at alternative ways to achieve the same result albeit through proven, safe methods that are sustainable and low-impact on the environment. Another important point to note is that there is much controversy over any inferences we make from laboratory and field trials that may be quite small and may not accurately reflect the true story on a large-scale.

Unfortunately, we also simply do not have international laws and regulations to provide ways to assess the impact of GM organisms. Hopefully, a realistic set of guidelines might eventually be created to address the concerns of GM organisms and the environmental impact. The interpretation of any gathered data regarding this impact could vary from one country to another, which means that guidelines would also need to include standards for accurate interpretation and actions to be taken.

Future of GM Crops and the Environment

Any type of agriculture has some effect on the environment, measurable or not. GM technology could potentially amplify the typical environmental damages from agriculture but it could do the exact opposite and help to contribute to better techniques and farming habits. Until more research is performed, it is likely to remain a waiting game that is filled with controversy. Researchers must assess the impact of each individual crop and compare merits and risks to the crop's non-GM counterparts. Ultimately, GM technology holds promise but still requires much more research before we can proceed without caution.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Topics
Latest Comments
  • Chris
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    Hi, my name is Chris Bennett and I am 57 years old. Two years ago my adopted son died in a car crash and now a month ago a man turned up at…
    25 April 2018
  • Jadedjamie
    Re: DNA Testing for Disease
    Can you DNA test for Lyme disease?
    25 April 2018
  • Ton
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    Hello, my sister was adopted when her biological mother gave her up at 5 by my mother and father. Both my parents are now decreased and my…
    25 April 2018
  • ExploreDNA
    Re: Using DNA and for Immigration Purposes
    bb - Your Question:I have 3 sons and 2 are not my husband's only one. Now my husband want me and the kids to join him…
    17 April 2018
  • ExploreDNA
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    Kiyyah - Your Question:Hi I'm 21 I got pregnant last year in February but I don't know who the father is cause it's three possible guy's and…
    11 April 2018
  • Kiyyah
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    Hi I'm 21 I got pregnant last year in February but i don't know who the father is cause it's three possible guy's and one just got killed…
    10 April 2018
  • Aniva
    Re: STR Analysis - Short Tandem Repeat
    Hello, May I know if there would be any difference in the number of STR Loci used to detect DNA Matches, i.e. would the…
    9 April 2018
  • Denise
    Re: DNA Testing for Pets
    Can you dna my dogs ashes to determine breed? I do not think I got the proper cremains back and I'm very angry. I also have clippings of her…
    5 April 2018
  • ExploreDNA
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    Bear - Your Question:My son was born not breathing on the 28th of March. It's now the 31st can a DNA test still be done? I am also though…
    4 April 2018
  • Bear
    Re: DNA Test after Death
    My son was born not breathing on the 28th of March. It's now the 31st can a DNA test still be done? I am also though only person on his death…
    1 April 2018
Further Reading...
Our Most Popular...
Add to my Yahoo!
Add to Google
Stumble this
Add to Twitter
Add To Facebook
RSS feed
You should seek independent professional advice before acting upon any information on the ExploreDNA website. Please read our Disclaimer.